Business

Retirement Plan Decisions When Selling a Closely Held Business

Retirement Plan Decisions When Selling a Closely Held Business

When an owner sells a closely held business, the company retirement plan needs its own decision. In a stock sale, the plan usually goes with the company unless the seller terminates it before closing, which buyers often require. In an asset sale, the seller generally keeps the plan, and employees who move to the buyer can usually take distributions or roll over their balances. Decide early, because some choices must be made before the closing date.

Business owners preparing for a sale spend months on valuation, financing and deal terms. The company 401(k) or pension plan often comes up late, sometimes in the final weeks of due diligence. By then, options can be limited and fixes more expensive.

The plan matters for two groups. Employees depend on it for their own retirement savings. And for many owners of closely held companies, the plan holds a meaningful share of their personal wealth outside the business itself.

Stock sale or asset sale: why the structure decides the plan’s fate

The single biggest factor is how the deal is structured.

  • Stock sale. The buyer acquires the legal entity, and with it the entity’s obligations, including the retirement plan. Unless the seller acts first, the plan continues under new ownership, along with any past compliance problems.
  • Asset sale. The buyer purchases the business’s assets, not the entity. The seller generally keeps the plan. Employees hired by the buyer typically have a severance from employment with the seller, which usually allows them to take distributions or roll their balances into an IRA or the buyer’s plan.

The timing rule that catches sellers off guard

In a stock sale where the buyer already sponsors its own 401(k), the buyer frequently asks the seller to terminate the company’s 401(k) before the deal closes. There is a technical reason.

Under IRS rules, a 401(k) plan generally cannot be terminated with distributions to participants if the employer maintains another defined contribution plan, known as an alternative plan, around the time of termination. Once the deal closes, the seller’s company becomes part of the buyer’s group. If the buyer has its own 401(k), terminating the old plan after closing can block distributions and force a merger instead.

The usual solution is a board resolution terminating the seller’s 401(k) effective no later than the day before closing. Miss that window, and the parties may have to merge plans, which brings the old plan’s history and any errors into the buyer’s plan.

What employees are owed when a plan ends

When a plan is fully terminated, all affected participants become 100% vested in their accounts, regardless of the plan’s normal vesting schedule. That can change the cost of the transaction if many employees have unvested employer contributions.

A sale can also trigger a partial plan termination even if the plan continues. The IRS generally presumes a partial termination when more than 20% of participants are let go by the employer in a plan year. Affected participants must then be fully vested as well.

If participants will be unable to make changes to their accounts for more than three business days during a transition, they generally must receive a written blackout notice at least 30 days in advance.

Pension plans need more lead time

Owners of closely held businesses sometimes sponsor a defined benefit plan alongside a 401(k). Ending one takes longer. A single-employer pension plan covered by the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation can end through a standard termination only if it has enough assets to pay all benefits, and participants must receive a notice of intent to terminate 60 to 90 days before the proposed termination date.

Because of that timeline, a pension plan termination often needs to start well before a letter of intent is signed. Owners should also understand whether the plan is fully funded, since a shortfall may need to be covered before or at closing.

Clean up before the buyer looks

Buyers routinely review retirement plans during due diligence. Common findings include late deposits of employee contributions, missed eligible employees, failed nondiscrimination tests and gaps between the plan document and how the plan actually runs.

Many of these problems can be corrected through the IRS Employee Plans Compliance Resolution System or the Department of Labor’s Voluntary Fiduciary Correction Program. Fixing issues before a sale is usually cheaper than negotiating over them at the closing table.

The owner’s own account

For the selling owner, the plan is also a personal planning question. Steven J. Musmanno, Chief Investment Officer of APS Pension & Financial Services in Melville, New York, works with closely held businesses on how their retirement plans are invested. He views the company plan as one way owners can diversify away from business equity risk, since many hold most of their net worth in the company they built. A sale changes that picture overnight, which is why the owner’s retirement account deserves the same attention as the deal proceeds.

Points to settle include:

  • Whether to roll the account into an IRA, a new employer’s plan or leave it in place if the plan continues
  • How outstanding plan loans will be handled. A loan offset at plan termination can generally be rolled over until the owner’s tax return due date, including extensions
  • How the retirement account fits with the investment of the sale proceeds, so the overall portfolio is not unintentionally concentrated or duplicated

A simple timeline for sellers

  1. Before marketing the business: review plan documents, testing results and Form 5500 filings, and correct errors.
  2. Before the letter of intent: decide whether a pension plan should be terminated, and start the process if so.
  3. During negotiation: agree with the buyer on whether the 401(k) will be terminated, merged or kept, and who bears the costs.
  4. Before closing: adopt any termination resolution and send required notices.
  5. After closing: complete distributions or transfers and file the plan’s final Form 5500.

Frequently asked questions

Does a buyer have to take over my 401(k) plan?

Not necessarily. In a stock sale the plan comes with the company unless it is terminated first, and buyers often ask the seller to terminate it before closing. In an asset sale, the seller usually keeps the plan.

Do employees lose unvested money when the business is sold?

If the plan is terminated, or a partial termination occurs, affected participants become fully vested. Employees’ own salary deferrals are always fully vested.

When should a seller start thinking about the retirement plan?

Ideally a year or more before a sale, especially if there is a pension plan. At minimum, before the letter of intent is signed.

This article is general information, not legal, tax or investment advice. Business owners should consult qualified ERISA, tax and transaction professionals about their own situation. Steven J. Musmanno is an investment adviser representative of APS Wealth Management, LLC, an SEC registered investment adviser. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training.

Related posts

Adeboa Aderinto Reveals Shocking Truths About Disparate Impact

Typarchive

Shernetrice Bryant on Establishing Credit for Your First Business

Typarchive

Learn how to get started in a sports market career

Mathew Despins

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This

Share this post with your friends!